Please keep the forum protocol in mind when posting.

Article Discussion » Post: Miscommunication? You need to make a decision!

Miscommunication? You need to make a decision!

Oct. 1, 2015 12:54:02 PM

Alexey Chernyshov
Judge (Level 2 (International Judge Program)), Scorekeeper

Europe - East

Miscommunication? You need to make a decision!

Kevin Desprez - Miscommunication? You need to make a decision!

As a judge, you have several options here:
Rule Dromoka’s Command has resolved and Magma Spray is on the stack
Rule Dromoka’s Command is on the stack and Magma Spray was cast in response
Rule Dromoka’s Command is on the stack and put Magma Spray back to AP’s hand

Option 1 is making a ruling in favor of NAP, while options 2 and 3 mean making a ruling in favor of AP (2 being harsher on AP).

I believe this should read "(2 being harsher on NAP)", not AP, because it is NAP casting Magma Spray in this scenario.

Edited Alexey Chernyshov (Oct. 1, 2015 12:54:51 PM)

Oct. 1, 2015 01:00:38 PM

Kevin Desprez
Judge (Level 3 (Judge Academy)), Scorekeeper

France

Miscommunication? You need to make a decision!

Correct.
When I simplified the scenario, I failed to proofread efficiently. Thanks for pointing it out!

Kevin.