Originally posted by John Carter:
The way we've handled this is to open only enough color or faction cases to handle the current event. So if our event is 88 players, we'd open 18 of the 5-colors cases (90 players worth). That little bit of overage allows some flexibility, without punishing players in later events.
Generally speaking, our players are understanding enough of both player's desires for specific things and our attempt to share the wealth across many events that they play along pretty well. Some people will wind up with second-choice colors, but very few have to go for a third choice.
John, I'm so glad I'm not the only one that does this! I give additional fun things out that are based upon the number of wins each color gets at the end of each event so having one event with all of the ‘white’ players would really be imbalanced. Taking pre-registrations for colors to give players a better chance to get their first choice has also increased the number of pre-registered players so I can be better prepared for each event!
At about 11:50 I ask players to get seated and start going over announcements. I give players a chance to ask questions about any cards or interactions then at exactly midnight I start handing out the packs, in order of registration. Players get their pack and are told not to open it until I let them. At this time, the players are discussing what they are hoping to get and possible combos. It usually only takes about 5-10 minutes to get everyone their packs (this is for a 50-75 player event).
This has worked really well since I put it into placed with RTR.